Illegal Antibiotics in Milk: What the FDA report means for organic

Photo Credit: B Garrett Photo Credit: B Garrett

A study was recently conducted by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) investigating almost 2,000 dairy farms for antibiotic contamination in milk. The FDA report showed that a small proportion of milk had residues of illegal antibiotics, causing worry about the use of drugs barred from use the dairy market. Milk shipments are only tested for six of the most widely used antibiotics, so some farmers appear to be avoiding detection by using antibiotics that aren't included in the standard test, because they aren't approved for use in lactating dairy cows.

Fortunately, the incidences of illegal drug use are low:  between 0.4 and 1%. Some FDA representatives have claimed their findings as encouraging, because the report shows low levels of violations. However, just because illegal antibiotic use statistics are considered low by the FDA, this report still means that up to one out of every hundred milk samples are “hot.” Additionally, even when illegal antibiotics are not used, it is very common for conventional farmers to use legal antibiotics in the dairy production.

Photo Credit: Dave Young Photo Credit: Dave Young

Coming from the organic perspective, it is important to remember that people don’t choose organic because they are worried that conventional products contain illegal drug residues:  people choose organic because they want to avoid any synthetic chemical residues at all. The organic standards prohibit the use of products like synthetic pesticides, antibiotics, and hormones, and they have consistently been found to have lower levels of these chemicals than conventional products, and that eating an organic diet can reduce the levels of pesticides in your body.

Additionally, when it comes to the use of antibiotics in animal rearing, we have more to worry about than the use of illegal drugs. Agricultural use of antibiotics has been in the news a lot this year because of the rise in antibiotic-resistant bacteria. The use of antibiotics in animals is 100 to 1,000 times higher annually than the use in the human population, and this widespread use of antibiotics in agriculture selects for bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics. These bacteria can be passed to humans through contact with livestock, manure, or food produced from the livestock (dairy, meat, eggs). The Center for Disease Control put out a report showing that over 2 million illnesses and 23 thousand deaths are caused by antibiotic-resistant bacteria every year. In 2014, the World Health organization declared antibiotic-resistant bacteria a global health epidemic.

Regardless of the FDA report findings, it is important to choose organic if you are worried about the presence of antibiotics or antibiotic-resistant bacteria. There are several studies that have shown that you can reduce your exposure to antibiotic-resistant bacteria through choosing organic. If that isn't enough to convince you, then remember that organic has a better nutritional profile and doesn't use hormones or pesticides in dairy feed!

antibiotics, dairy, pesticides, science, resistance